Skip to main content
Colleen Sedgwick holding a small white dog, with the title 4 Out-of-the-Box Ways to Find Great Pet Sitters

4 Out-of-the-Box Ways to Find Great Pet Sitters

Your job ad is live. The applications trickle in. Half of them never answer your follow-up text, and the other half ghost the interview.

Sound familiar? Here’s the truth: the best pet sitters are often already in your world, one or two introductions away. When my own team was stretched thin, these four out-of-the-box moves brought in some of the best sitters I’ve ever hired.

1. Ask your people to post for you in local neighborhood groups

Neighborhood apps like Nextdoor only let you post in the area where you live. If your service area is big, that leaves a lot of neighborhoods you can’t reach on your own.

So ask for help. Reach out to friends, family and your current sitters who live in different parts of your service area, and ask them to share your opening in their neighborhood feed. Give them a short, ready-to-paste post with a link to your application so it takes them two minutes.

2. Invite great former sitters back

Make a list of every past sitter you loved working with. Life changes. Kids go back to school, schedules open up, and side income starts to sound good again.

Send a short, warm note: “Hey! We’re growing and hiring. You were one of my favorites. Any interest in coming back?” One email to my past sitters brought in several interested people. They already know your systems, so training is quick.

3. Tell your clients you’re hiring

Your clients already trust your business, and they know people who love animals: retired neighbors, college students home for the summer, friends looking for flexible work.

Send a quick email or add a line to your newsletter: “We’re hiring! Here’s why sitters love working with us.” Share what makes your team a great place to work, and ask them to pass it along. Referrals from clients tend to be a strong fit.

4. Post in local Facebook groups

This is one of the easiest ways to find people close to the visits you need covered. Search Facebook for your town and service area names, open the Groups tab, and join the community groups that come up.

Ask each admin if you can share a job post. Some will say no, and that’s okay. The ones who say yes give you access to a whole community of local animal lovers.

Make your post friendly and specific: the areas you need covered, the type of visits, the schedule, and a link to apply.

Make hiring an ongoing system

These four moves work best when they’re part of an ongoing system. Keep a short list of interested candidates all year so you aren’t starting from zero when the busy season hits.

Want the full process, from your ideal sitter profile to onboarding? Read How to Hire Pet Sitters: The Complete Guide, and see how to put your sitter recruiting on autopilot before you need help.

If you’d like hands-on help building your hiring system and your team, CEO Academy walks you through it step by step. Your future self will thank you.

Watch the original video

I first shared these tips during a hiring crunch in 2021. The strategies still work today.

Colleen Sedgwick, founder of Pet Nanny Coach

About Colleen Sedgwick

Colleen is the founder of Pet Nanny Coach and PetSitterVA. She started Pet Nanny, Pet Sitters of the Main Line, in 2001 after leaving her teaching career, and has spent 25 years building and leading a pet sitting company with a team. Today she coaches pet sitting and dog walking business owners to build businesses that run without them.

More about Colleen  |  See how CEO Academy works

hiring pet sitters, how to grow my pet sitting business, how to run a pet sitting business, pet sitting business coach, Pet sitting business coaching

Pet Nanny Coach
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.